Join Andrew Weil, Deepak Chopra, and other health
leaders to dialogue about Proactive Health

The Better Health Campaign : www.Health-Journalist.com
Brings You Together with Health Leaders to Access Full Spectrum Options in Health Care
Empower Your Health : Expand Your Health Care Options : Assure Your Health Freedoms


   ALISON ROSE LEVY'S HUFFINGTON POST BLOGS:

Don't Drink the Water: Overcoming Complacency in Health Reporting
Posted March 15, 2008

The media’s selling the Iraq war prompts outrage, yet the typical reporter’s eager acceptance of health reports and spins by the government and vested medical interests passes for “objective science.”

Health investigative journalism is an endangered species. So here’s kudos to the trio of Associated Press reporters, who recently undertook an independent investigation into the contamination of the water supplies by pharmaceutical drugs.

Delving past the official denials and half truths to review water tests or test independently, the AP team found that 41 million Americans drink water contaminated by antidepressants, hormones, heart medications and other prescription and over the counter meds. The substances excreted by those taking them end up in the water supply. Standard water treatment methods don’t remove them.

Millions of people, (down to young children prescribed psychiatric medications) take meds, but those who don’t also imbibe a weird chemical brew. Scientists don’t know how small quantities of a wide variety of agents never intended to be taken together interact in our bodies, or among themselves, where unintended toxic synergies can result.

Do those chemicals really find their way into us?

In Bill Moyers’ 2001 PBS special Trade Secrets, testing revealed that Moyers had a eighty-four different chemicals in his bodily tissues. But until mass use drives down testing costs, few can afford similar tests.

What we don’t know could be hurting us but don’t count on reading all about it.

Unlike Moyers and the AP team, health coverage rarely probes the interconnection between personal and environmental health.

Instead the media purveys the latest research finding as “objective proof,” overlooking the vested interests that typically pay for the research, and quickly bury studies that don’t support the sponsor’s intended product claims.

Scrutiny is called for. In a number of federal regulatory agencies with oversight on food and health, so-called public servants regularly traipse to and fro the industries they supposedly regulate.

For example, aspartame, a known neurotoxin, gained FDA approval when Donald Rumsfeld (then Chairman of Searle, the aspartame patent holder) reportedly played a role in the appointment of Reagan’s FDA commissioner. Soon after breaking a tie at the panel that approved aspartame, this commissioner left the FDA, going on to serve as the PR czar for the companies producing aspartame.

Few journalists face up to a compromised policy context. Nevertheless, it shapes what's regulated, what's studied, how it's studied, what's regarded as "proof" in a study, what's stamped as "safe," and what's targeted as "dangerous," and what makes it on to a label and into our bodies, food supply, water supply, and the earth.

Instead of navigating this complex context, the health media either proffers “health tips” or offers information uncritically as if it descended from a scientific ivory tower, untainted by economic interest.

All of these factors will meet in addressing the widespread contamination of the water supply.

As researchers attempt to get their hands around the problem, standard health science research may prove inadequate. Our current research model developed to target substances patentable as drugs, not to explore the complexity of the human organism and the multiple influences (biochemical, psychological, and spiritual) upon it. Targeting only a single agent (as either cause or treatment) overlooks three factors:

A. Biochemical individuality, which causes people to react differently to various agents.

B. Multi-factorial impacts, in which multiple agents act together synergistically, or in unpredictable ways, beyond the limits of single agent testing to identify.

C. Environmental impacts

If many factors act in synergy to produce harm, testing only one, as we commonly do “proves” nothing. Although each individual drug in our water supply is considered “safe” for use by some people, researching and isolating a single agent tells us nothing about the real health dangers of environmental contamination by multiple agents. We need to reassess the assumption that the earth and its creatures, including us, have infinite capacity to dilute whatever we dump.

“The chemical stress that’s put on any organism is the result of minute stresses of a multitude of chemicals,” says Christopher Daughton, the EPA’s chief of environmental chemistry in a recent article in Chemical and Engineering News on the impact of drugs in water on wildlife, which has resulted in the feminization of certain species of fish, whose males now bear eggs.

It’s the job of health reporting to connect the dots on some of these sad realities, and their attendant risk to human, animal, and global health.

But if instead you next read headlines about a study that refutes any potential health problem from drug contaminated water, don’t forget:

Deniability has a bottom line: the hefty price tags for the clean-up and health harm. Unless well-informed people call for a collective accounting for health risks and impacts, individuals will be forced to dig into their own pockets to cover the damages. Those interested in collective health journalism and action can sign up at: www.health-journalist.com

Copyright, 2008, Alison Rose Levy. All rights reserved.

WANT TO USE THIS ARTICLE IN YOUR E-ZINE OR WEB SITE?
You can, as long as you include this complete blurb with it:
Alison Rose Levy, MA, health journalist, bestselling writer, and Communications Director of the Better Health Campaign blogs on Huffington Post, Intentblog and other sites. To join leading health experts in a consumer movement for full options in Proactive Health care, please sign up for the Health Journalist’s ezine on at: www.health-journalist.com For current workshop signups go to: www.eventbrite.com/org/34806955?s=869739
Copyright © 2008 Alison Rose Levy. All rights reserved.

 
Since 1990, I’ve been writing, reporting, and contemplating the manifold dimensions of health in
bestselling books, national magazine articles, blogs, TV and radio programs, and websites. Contact
the Better Health Campaign at Alison@health-journalist.com or visit my Huffington Post blogs here

© Copyright 2008 All Rights Reserved - Alison Rose Levy